California’s Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) found that a holding company and the operating LLC whose interest it sold were not unitary, which means the resulting gain is nonbusiness income allocable outside California—not business income apportionable to the state. In the Matter of the Consolidated Appeals of M.L. Watts and C.A. Watts, and C. Watts and M. Watts, the OTA reversed the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) and held that Watts Holdings, Inc. (WHI) and Sunstate Equipment Co., LLC (Sunstate) were not engaged in a unitary business in December 2012.
As a result, the OTA found that WHI’s gain from the December 2012 sale of its 44.935% membership interest in Sunstate was nonbusiness income allocable outside of California.
What Happened in the Watts Case?
On February 28, 2025, the OTA issued its underlying opinion reversing the FTB’s proposed assessments and finding that WHI and Sunstate were not engaged in a unitary business in December 2012. The FTB subsequently filed a timely petition for rehearing. In its opinion denying that petition, the OTA explained that the FTB did not identify a recognized ground or requested relief warranting rehearing and instead largely sought to revisit the underlying unitary-business issues, including arguments it had not raised or developed in the original briefing. The rehearing process has now concluded, and the OTA left the February 2025 decision and its findings undisturbed. For this reason, this article examines the details and implications of the February 2025 decision.
Sunstate operated an equipment rental business throughout the U.S., including California, and was treated as a partnership for federal income tax purposes. WHI was an Arizona holding company that elected S corporation status for 2012 and owned an interest in Sunstate. WHI also wholly owned Sunstate Aviation and Leasing, LLC (Aviation), an aircraft-leasing entity that leased aircraft to Sunstate and unrelated third parties.
In 2012, WHI received $149,900 from Sunstate, paid through Aviation, in connection with aircraft rental activity. Sumitomo, the acquiror, purchased its interest in Sunstate in phases. Initially, Sumitomo’s affiliate had acquired a 35% preferred interest in Sunstate on December 1, 2009. That preferred interest was later converted into common units, and amendments to Sunstate’s operating agreement expanded Sumitomo’s affiliate’s approval rights over major Sunstate decisions. In December 2012, WHI sold additional Sunstate units representing a 44.935% membership interest to Sumitomo’s affiliate. WHI’s 2012 California return reported a $153,908,352 long-term capital gain and a $93,023,003 ordinary gain from the sale. The FTB found that WHI and Sunstate were unitary at the time of the sale and asserted that the gain should be treated as apportionable business income rather than nonbusiness income allocable outside California.
Was WHI & Sunstate’s Business Unitary?
The core question was whether WHI and Sunstate operated as a unitary business in December 2012, since a unitary finding would make WHI’s gain on the sale apportionable business income for California purposes. The decision was fact-driven, but it arose against a familiar California sourcing framework.
California distinguishes between business income, which is apportioned among taxing states, and nonbusiness income, which is allocated to a specific state. For nonresident owners, income from intangibles is sourced outside California unless the intangible has acquired a California business situs. If WHI and Sunstate were unitary, the gain would be treated as apportionable business income. However, if WHI and Sunstate were not unitary, the gain would be treated as nonbusiness income allocable outside of California.
What Did the Taxpayers Argue?
M.L. Watts and C. Watts, California nonresident shareholders of WHI, argued that WHI and Sunstate were not unitary in December 2012 and that WHI’s gain on the sale was nonbusiness income allocable outside California.
The taxpayers maintained that the operational and managerial connections between WHI, Aviation, and Sunstate were insufficient to establish the centralized management and flow of value required for unity. They emphasized that Sumitomo’s affiliate held significant approval and veto rights over Sunstate’s major decisions and that those rights limited WHI’s ability to direct Sunstate as part of an integrated business enterprise.
What Did the OTA Decide?
The OTA found that WHI and Sunstate were not engaged in a unitary business in December 2012 and reversed the FTB’s action, treating WHI’s gain from the sale of its Sunstate interest as nonbusiness income allocable outside of California.
California recognizes two alternative unitary-business tests: the contribution or dependency test and the three-unities test. The contribution or dependency test looks to whether in-state activities contribute to or depend on out-of-state activities with a corresponding flow of value. The three-unities test examines unity of ownership, unity of operations, and unity of use through a general system of operations and a centralized executive force. There is considerable overlap between the two tests, and their application should produce the same result.
In the holding company context, California courts consider additional factors due to the entity’s limited operational activity. These factors include liability protection, conduit or focal-point ownership, intercompany financing, shared tax benefits, enhanced creditworthiness, noncompete agreements, the holding company’s control over the operating business, and other benefits provided to the operating entity. Conversely, common ownership and arm’s-length transactions between related parties, standing alone, are insufficient to establish a unitary relationship absent evidence of operational integration, centralized management, or meaningful control.
The OTA first addressed the FTB’s principal arguments that WHI and Sunstate were operationally integrated through aircraft use, overlapping officers and directors, and a covenant not to compete. The OTA found the aircraft-related activity limited in both size and significance: Sunstate’s aircraft rental expense from Aviation was $149,900, representing less than 10% of Sunstate’s 2012 travel expenditures. Sunstate’s use of Aviation aircraft also declined from 17% of flight seats in 2010 to 15% in 2011 and 8% in 2012. Based on those facts, the OTA concluded that the aircraft arrangements did not show meaningful operational integration between WHI and Sunstate. The OTA also found that overlapping officers and directors were insufficient to establish unity, particularly because Sumitomo’s affiliate held broad approval rights over major policy matters and was actively involved in Sunstate’s governance. Finally, although the covenant not to compete was relevant to the unitary-business inquiry, the OTA determined that it did not, by itself, establish a unitary relationship on the record presented.
The OTA then briefly applied the three-unities framework and concluded that WHI and Sunstate did not satisfy the test. Although the record reflected some common ownership and some overlapping personnel, the OTA found a lack of unity of operation because the evidence did not show meaningful centralized functions, operational integration, or intercompany activity sufficient to create a single integrated business. The OTA also viewed Sumitomo’s approval rights and governance involvement as inconsistent with an integrated executive force controlled by WHI. Accordingly, the OTA concluded that the three-unities test was not met.
What Does This Decision Mean for Multistate Business Owners?
This decision illustrates that the unitary-business determination for sourcing gain on the sale of an interest in a flow-through business can turn on the actual level of integration and control reflected in contemporaneous facts—not simply ownership percentage, historical relationships, or common branding.
Several practical takeaways flow from the decision:
- Businesses with S corp, partnership, or LLC ownership structures should look at whether an investment is truly unitary by looking at the actual unity of ownership, operation, and use or centralized management reflected in the facts.
- Where a third-party investor holds meaningful approval rights, taxpayers should preserve governance documents and evidence showing how those rights were exercised.
- Related-party transactions should be documented and supported by arm’s-length terms, particularly where the state may argue that those transactions show operational integration.
Taxpayers should also track and support flows of value through shared services, intercompany transactions, and common management based on magnitude and business significance. Nonresident owners with California-facing investments may want to revisit prior sourcing positions for refund opportunities, state inquiry exposure, and documentation support. The decision may also be relevant for Accounting Standards Codification 740 purposes, defenses in proceedings before the FTB and the OTA, and transaction planning where California sourcing, apportionment, or nonbusiness income positions are at issue. Although California applies single-sales-factor apportionment for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2013, this case involved a 2012 transaction and turned first on whether the gain was business income apportionable to California at all.
How Forvis Mazars Can Help
You do not have to untangle unitary-business questions on your own. Forvis Mazars can help businesses look at the impact of the OTA’s decision on California unitary-business findings, business/nonbusiness income classification, and gain sourcing or allocation positions for nonresident owners. Our state and local tax professionals can assist with documenting governance rights and related-party transactions, working through California income tax reporting positions, supporting defense in FTB and OTA proceedings, and identifying potential refund claim opportunities. If you have any questions or need assistance, please reach out to one of our professionals.