Episode 39: Impacts From the Midterm Election
Welcome back to “Tackling Tax,” where we’ll bring you the latest on tax policy and strategies—in an easy-to-understand format. Whether you’re looking to learn more about tax bills, global tax implications, or planning insights for your business, you’re in the right place.
Listen every other week for more from our guests, which include everyone from university scholars to industry professionals to the firm’s experienced leaders.
In this episode, we’ll discuss the midterm election results and their impact on the lame-duck session. We welcome Marc Gerson with Miller & Chevalier, who has served as majority tax counsel to the House Ways and Means Committee, to share his insights.
If you have any questions or need any assistance, please reach out to a professional at Forvis Mazars.
Transcript
IRIS LAWS
This episode, we’re focusing on the results of last week’s election. We’re pleased to welcome Mark Gerson from Miller and Chevalier to discuss the results and the impacts on the lame-duck session, as well as for the 120th Congress. From your one stop for tax updates and analysis, I’m Iris.
LANCE JACOBS
And I’m Lance.
IRIS LAWS
And this is “Tackling Tax.”
LANCE JACOBS
Iris, it’s an absolute pleasure to introduce our guest this week. He’s worked all over our industry in tax and government relations. He’s worked at several different law firms, in industry as tax counsel, as majority tax counsel for the House of Representatives Committee on Ways and Means, and if my math is right, he’s been at Miller and Chevalier for a little less than 20 years.
On a personal level, he’s been a friend for 35 years, and his tax outlines got me through law school, where he was a year ahead of me. It is my pleasure to introduce a fellow member of the George Washington Journal of International Law and Economics, the pride of Marlboro, New Jersey, and Camp Ranger in the Catskills, where I’m pretty sure he threw at my head in inter camp baseball game, Marc Gerson.
MARC GERSON
Thanks for having me today. Good to see you.
IRIS LAWS
All right, Marc, that was some introduction, man. But let’s start really high level. To put this bluntly, what the heck happened?
MARC GERSON
So, I mean, it was a very interesting election. Before the election, you know, was already kind of history making. We had a record number of House and Senate retirements, this unprecedented mid-decade redistricting fight. We had the president knocking out some Republican incumbents. And I think it’s fair to say, leading up to the election, maybe two months before, I think everyone was very solid in the notion that the Democrats would take the House and that the Senate was somewhat of a jump ball, but likely to stay in Republican control. I think kind of throughout the election, but certainly accelerated over the last number of months, was that Democrats were able to take advantage of kind of new and increasing opportunities all the time.
And Republicans, particularly in the Senate, were starting to show signs of weakness in traditionally red states, so some of the farm states, and that played through right through the election. And whether it was concerns about a number of topics, whether it was the economy, the Iranian war, gas prices, immigration policy, you know, the president’s, you know, focus on kind of vanity projects like the ballroom.
It all led to what some called a blue wave, but others are calling this blue tsunami, where you had Democrats essentially defend all of their seats and then have massive pickups both in the House and the Senate, giving them control of both bodies in the 120th.
LANCE JACOBS
So, Marc, would you say that it was about the two month ago marker where you kind of felt like this would be something more than the Democrats retaking control of the House, while the Republicans kept control of the Senate, and more of a moderate wave than a blue tsunami in the House?
MARC GERSON
I think that’s right. I mean, I think we did, you know, things were trending very much towards the Democrats favor in the House and Senate and that seemed to be accelerating as we got closer to the election day. I think no one really predicted it would be, you know, such a kind of massive and significant victory. And I think folks were surprised by a lot of the results.
LANCE JACOBS
Okay. So, without getting too much inside baseball here, Marc, can you, for our audience, just kind of give the “Schoolhouse Rock” quick overview of how a bill becomes a law, including concepts of reconciliation, vetoes and overriding the veto so we can kind of level-set it for the rest of the 119th and then the 120th?
MARC GERSON
Sure. So, 435 members in the House. 218 needed for a majority. 218 needed to pass legislation. The Senate is 100 members. Generally, it’s majority rule also, so, 51 votes. But what the Senate has is what’s called the cloture vote, where they need 60 votes to end debate and proceed to actually vote on a bill. And so, it really is a 60-vote threshold generally.
And then the exception to all this is the reconciliation process, which is a special budgetary rule that restricts what type of legislation can be part of a budget resolution, but allows in the Senate, instead of that 60-vote threshold, a 51-vote threshold. Layered on top of all of this, of course, is the threat of a presidential veto on legislation that has successfully passed the Congress requires a, you know, a two-thirds vote in order for that to override the veto.
IRIS LAWS
So, super helpful, right? I think, you know clearly how things shook out, the Senate is still short of a filibuster-proof majority on the Democratic side. More expansive majority on the House side, right? But we’ll circle back to maybe the implications for next Congress in a minute. Maybe, can we turn to this lame-duck session? What can we possibly expect for the remaining weeks of the 119th in the tax space, and maybe also more broadly?
MARC GERSON
Sure. So, you know, Congress returned this week to a massive agenda of kind of must-pass and like-to-pass items. The most prominent are funding the federal government. Government funding runs out December 11. There also is the annual defense policy bill—the NDAA, the National Defense Authorization Act that usually passes without incident on a bipartisan basis. That’s kind of must-pass legislation. Beyond that, there really are two potential vehicles that may have a tax element.
The first would be a partisan, Republican-only reconciliation bill, similar to what they use for purposes of the OB3 legislation that was passed in the summer of 2025. And I think what you will see play out is that the administration will put a lot of pressure on congressional Republicans to do what would be a third reconciliation bill, what they’re calling reconciliation 3.0, primarily for significant defense appropriations and defense spending, also could include the debt limit.
As currently envisioned right now, would not include a couple things. One, it would not include any of the kind of Save Act voting rights legislation that President Trump has been interested in. And it also, at this point, would not include a tax title. That potentially could change if, let’s say, they actually went through and tried to do reconciliation 3.0.
And the defense spending number got out of control. They might try to offset some of those costs with a tax title and tax increases. But I think a reconciliation 3.0 bill is pretty unlikely, even though it may be talked about, for a number of reasons. One, I think the morale of the Republican Party coming after the elections, the limited amount of time they have, where they do want to devote to other things like permitting reform and then funding the government and obviously confirmation of nominees.
The fact that they’ll have attendance issues both in the House and Senate, you have members who have lost who don’t want to stick around through the holidays. And then I think there’s still a lot of intraparty dispute among Republicans about kind of the scope and content of a reconciliation bill. So, I think a reconciliation exercise is really kind of doomed for failure.
At the same time, as long as Republicans are talking about reconciliation. It’ll make it very politically difficult for Democrats to engage in kind of a traditional year-end bipartisan bill. And that’s a bill—there’s a lot of bipartisan tax relief, some of it’s, you know, in introduced bills, some of it’s been through one or both of the tax writing committees, some of it’s been through the House floor—but we’re talking about extenders like WOTC and 48D, we’re talking about tax administration, crypto tax, retirement, U.S.-Taiwan tax relief. A real, like, kind of critical mass of bipartisan tax relief that the parties could easily agree to.
Aside from the fact that reconciliation may be in the air, that bill would have its own challenges. One is time. Another is, are the parties in a bipartisan mood given, you know, hurt feelings from the midterms? Another would be it would probably have to be not offset. So, no tax increases. Very hard for the parties to agree on tax increases, particularly in a condensed period of time. And then I think the other thing is that, you know, Democrats are certainly supportive of this package of business tax relief.
We talked about like extenders, U.S.-Taiwan. The question is whether they would also insist on, let’s say, an equal amount of individual tax relief. And primarily, if Democrats only agree to this business tax relief package, if there is an extension of the expired ACA premium tax credit, the package likely falls apart. And so, I think we’re at a point in the year where there could be a reconciliation bill that maybe has tax.
There could be a bipartisan bill that most certainly would have tax. But there’s also a real chance that we don’t have any of that. They, you know, spend a couple of weeks being mad at each other and doing leadership elections. And then they find a way to fund the government on a temporary basis through a CR. Maybe they handle the debt limit. They do energy permitting. The Senate does confirmations and they go home. No tax legislation.
LANCE JACOBS
And that CR, Marc, is due, the money runs out for the government on December 11. Do I have my date right?
MARC GERSON
Yeah, it’s December 11th. So, it’s the general funding for the government and it’s also for the highway trust fund runs out the same day.
LANCE JACOBS
Okay. And one more follow-up question just to clarify. I was under the impression, possibly mistaken, that a reconciliation bill had to be revenue-neutral. So, if you’re talking about layering on a whole bunch of defense spending, would you not have to find cuts to kind of offset that spending, or no?
MARC GERSON
Well, a reconciliation bill, the underlying budget resolution can have a deficit impact. But generally, what happens is that if the committees of jurisdiction have a bill that has more tax relief or more spending than that number, they have to include tax increases to get it down to the number in the budget resolution.
LANCE JACOBS
All right. So, looking ahead to the 120th Congress, and it sounds like the end of the 119th is going to be a little bit of a mess, what can we reasonably expect? You know, you kind of alluded to this, but I would think that the conditions are rife for some internal soul searching in the Republican Party, to say the least.
And there’s certainly a lot of diversity of thought in the Democratic Party as well. When you combine that with a lame duck president and the 2028 presidential coming up relatively quickly, it seems like you have a whole bunch of constituencies that may have differing agendas that doesn’t really bode well for potential legislation. Am I right in my thinking here, or am I being too dramatic?
MARC GERSON
I don’t think you’re being too dramatic, Lance. I think the baseline assumption is that we’re in divided government. Presidential election season starts early, like you mentioned, and that it really, the legislative agenda would be really limited to must-pass legislation.
So, further government funding, dealing with the debt limit, but no real opportunities for tax legislation. And instead, what you would have on the Democratic side is kind of messaging bills—maybe through reconciliation and forcing a presidential veto—that have significant tax increases, address affordability, all for messaging and setting the platform for 2028, knowing the president’s going to veto, you know, the passed legislation.
And on the Republican side, I think you would have obviously, they continue to do work on the administrative side. So, you would see, for example, you know, the reproposed CAMT regulations, very active on tariffs, you know, that type of kind of executive action.
And you’d probably see a lot of messaging touting the benefits of OB3, particularly because a lot of the kind of populist provisions in that bill—so, no tax on tips, the deductions for seniors, the deductions for domestic car loan interest, the Trump accounts—those all expire at the end of 2028. So, you see a lot of messaging and again, no real legislation.
The wild card is the president. And so, is he going to be as he talked about this week Mr. Veto, or is he going to be Mr. Art Of The Deal and want to work with Democrats on some bipartisan priorities? And that may seem far-fetched, but the president, and it’s really hard to see which way this goes, but it is important to reference that, you know, during consideration of OB3, the president endorsed some pretty significant kind of, again, populist tax increases that didn’t make it in the final legislation.
So, talked about carried interest, talked about a so-called billionaires tax, which was really kind of a reinstatement of the 39.6% rate. Those are proposals Democrats could be supportive of.
And so, then perhaps it provides some revenue for some bipartisan tax relief. Now, that may be this bipartisan tax relief that we talked about in, you know, for a potential year-end bill in lame duck. So, if that doesn’t happen—extenders, tax administration, crypto—that could be kind of the formulation of a bipartisan package in the next Congress.
You could also see things that, you know, housing, for example, where there was this bipartisan housing bill, but there wasn’t a tax title. So, maybe that’s some area. So, I think odds are, you know, it’s divided government. It’s really nasty. The parties can’t agree on anything. And even the basic blocking and tackling requires a lot of negotiation.
So, no real tax legislation unless the president kind of embraces it and it’d really be the president working with congressional Democrats on some type of bipartisan package.
IRIS LAWS
What about tariffs, right? I mean, is there really anything that Congress can do on that front?
MARC GERSON
I mean, I do think there will be a legitimate effort by the Democrats to try to take back some of the control of the tariff process and perhaps a willingness of some Republicans, you know, kind of protecting the institution of the Congress to take back some of the power. Again, I think the administration leans heavily into tariffs despite perhaps the bad, you know, public view it got in the elections because it’s something they arguably still have a lot of executive power to do.
So, I think on one hand you could have the administration leaning harder into their tariff authority, the Congress trying to pull it back, but perhaps maybe with not real practical impact.
LANCE JACOBS
So, Marc, I have another question for you. And it’s kind of at the intersection of where my state and local tax world and your federal tax world kind of combine. And this is something I think you and I talked about back in January or February, which is the Home Rule Act, which is a federal law that means that if the District of Columbia Council passes any sort of law—not just a tax law, but any law—Congress has 30 days from when the Council submits it to them for approval to pass, quote unquote, resolutions of disapproval.
And that basically invalidates the tax law in the D.C. code and from the D.C. Council’s point of view. They famously did that with some of the OBBBA decoupling stuff. But I would think with the makeup of the Congress now, to the extent that they wanted to permanently decouple from that, I would think that the Democratic control of both houses would make that a nonstarter, and that the D.C. Council should be able to get its legislation through and be approved essentially by Congress. I wonder if you have any thoughts on that?
MARC GERSON
Yeah. I mean, I think the likelihood has done up significantly. I wouldn’t think of it as a definite or rubber stamp. I do think there will be some Democrats who want to think about kind of the precedential value, and what it means for like what other states are doing. So, obviously odds, I mean, before was obviously like there was going to be a resolution and it’d be, you know, kind of taken out, the odds have increased dramatically. But I don’t think it’s necessarily kind of 100% probability.
LANCE JACOBS
And then the other thing I would add, which is just, again from my world, again, differentiating it from the federal, you do have a handful of states that just got some Democratic trifectas, probably most notably Pennsylvania. So, I think you could see some state tax legislation in some of those states. And then there are some states that had trifecta and lost them. So, I think you’ll probably see more of the gridlock at the state level. But I do think over the next two years, given the gridlock, to the extent that there’s impact tax legislation, I would expect it to be at the state tax level.
MARC GERSON
Yeah, I think that’s right.
IRIS LAWS
Well, Marc, I think that’s our discussion for today. Sounds like it should be an interesting couple of months. And then, you know, a couple of years after that. But, well, if you’ll have us, we would love to have you back maybe sometime next year to check on how things are going.
MARC GERSON
That sounds great. Thank you for the nice discussion and the opportunity.
IRIS LAWS
Thanks, Marc.
LANCE JACOBS
Thanks, Marc.
IRIS LAWS
And that’s our show. Thanks for joining. Remember to subscribe and listen in for the next episode of the podcast. Until next time.
ANNOUNCER
The information set forth in this podcast contains the analysis and conclusions of the panelists based upon his, her, or their research and analysis of industry information and legal authorities. Such analyses and conclusions should not be deemed opinions or conclusions by Forvis Mazars or the panelists as to any individual situation as situations are fact specific.
The listener should perform their own analysis and form their own conclusions regarding any specific situation. Further, the panelists’ conclusions may be revised without notice, with or without changes in industry information and legal authorities.