Regulatory Update: Ninth Circuit Ruling on California Scope 3 Reporting
On November 9, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a preliminary-injunction ruling affecting California’s climate disclosure requirements. The court left Senate Bill (SB) 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting requirements in place but reversed the district court’s denial of preliminary injunctive relief related to Scope 3 reporting. The court concluded that the Scope 3 requirements are likely unconstitutional under the First Amendment and remanded the case for the district court to determine whether those provisions are severable from the remainder of SB 253.
What this means: The future of California’s mandatory Scope 3 reporting requirement is now uncertain. However, organizations may still benefit from building their Scope 3 data, measurement, and assessment capabilities as regulatory requirements evolve in California and other jurisdictions.
Scope 3 emissions, the indirect emissions generated across a company’s upstream and downstream value chain, are typically the largest and most complex portion of an organization’s carbon footprint, and they sit at the center of emerging climate disclosure requirements.
While the Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol recognizes 15 Scope 3 categories, the California Air Resources Board proposed a phased approach for California’s climate disclosure requirements. Prior to the Ninth Circuit’s November 2026 decision, CARB had proposed a phased approach to Scope 3 reporting, beginning with five commonly reported categories: Categories 1, 3, 5, 6, and 7. While the future of California’s mandatory Scope 3 requirements is now uncertain, understanding these categories can still help organizations develop their emissions inventories and prepare for evolving reporting expectations.
Building a Scope 3 Inventory: Five Categories to Consider
Category 1: Purchased Goods & Services
This category captures emissions from the extraction, production, and transportation of goods and services a company purchases during the reporting year. It is often the largest Scope 3 category because it reflects the entire upstream supply chain, including raw materials, packaging, equipment, software and cloud services, and professional services. Companies frequently begin with spend-based data, then move toward supplier-specific data as a key decarbonization strategy.
Example: A manufacturer’s purchases of steel and plastic components fall here, even though the emissions occur at the supplier.
Category 3: Fuel- & Energy-Related Activities
Category 3 captures upstream emissions from producing the fuel and energy a company consumes. These emissions occur before the fuel or electricity reaches the organization and are, therefore, excluded from Scope 1 and Scope 2. The category includes upstream emissions of purchased fuels and electricity, transmission and distribution losses, and electricity purchased for resale. Existing Scope 1 and 2 data is often the starting point.
Example: When a company burns diesel in fleet vehicles, Scope 1 captures combustion while Category 3 captures the fuel’s extraction, processing, and transport.
Category 5: Waste Generated in Operations
This category includes emissions from treating and disposing of waste produced during normal operations, such as landfill trash, manufacturing scrap, recycling, composting, and wastewater treatment. Although the waste leaves the company’s operational control, the resulting emissions remain attributable to its operations.
Example: A manufacturer’s scrap metal disposal and an office’s paper and food waste both generate reportable emissions.
Category 6: Business Travel
Business travel covers emissions from employee travel on transportation the company does not own or operate, including flights, rail, rental cars, ride-booking services, and, depending on methodology, hotel stays. Data typically comes from travel agencies, expense reports, or booking systems.
Insight from Forvis Mazars: Organizations often prioritize this category because the data is relatively accessible and travel decisions can be influenced through policy and virtual-meeting alternatives.
Category 7: Employee Commuting
This category captures emissions from employees traveling between home and work. Although these emissions occur outside company assets and working hours, they are an indirect consequence of maintaining a workforce.
Insight from Forvis Mazars: Organizations commonly estimate them through employee surveys covering transportation mode, distance, frequency, and remote-work days, and many evaluate remote-work or commuter-incentive programs as reduction opportunities.
Future Reporting & Relevancy Assessments
The remaining 10 categories should not be ignored as CARB’s proposed Scope 3 reporting requirements remain subject to change. In addition, other regulations around the world—the European Union’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and Australia’s AASB S2 regulation, for example—require full material scope 3 disclosure. As reporting programs mature, organizations should perform a formal relevancy and materiality assessment to determine which additional categories warrant inclusion. Companies should evaluate each remaining category against established criteria for alignment with the GHG Protocol:
- Size of emissions: categories expected to represent a significant share of total Scope 3 emissions, e.g., Capital Goods or Upstream Transportation for a manufacturer.
- Influence: categories where management decisions, such as supplier selection or freight optimization, can drive meaningful reductions.
- Risk exposure: categories tied to regulatory, financial, operational, supply chain, litigation, or reputational risk.
- Stakeholder expectations: categories investors, customers, or regulators expect to see disclosed, even if smaller by volume.
- Outsourced activities: categories where functions once performed internally (warehousing, manufacturing, or data centers) have shifted to third parties.
- Sector-specific guidance: categories consistently material within an industry, such as Use of Sold Products for appliance makers or Investments for financial institutions.
- Other company/industry-specific factors: criteria tailored to the business, such as major spend categories, revenue drivers, acquisitions, or emerging regulations.
Organizations can evaluate the remaining categories against these criteria and conclude whether the corresponding Scope 3 category is relevant for emissions calculation and disclosure.
Conclusion
At CARB’s October 2026 board meeting, staff indicated they are continuing to evaluate Scope 3 reporting requirements, including how materiality should be defined and Scope 3 categories reporting entities should be required to report. A phased approach lets organizations establish a solid Scope 3 foundation by focusing first on purchased goods and services, fuel- and energy-related activities, waste, business travel, and employee commuting. A formal relevancy assessment guides which of the remaining categories are relevant.
Building your data foundation well today can make adapting to future evolutions of these regulations easier. Using technology as the backbone of your measurement can improve the data quality of your scope 3 measurements and give you a transparent data lineage for answering future assurance questions. If requirements shift in the future, the automation of a data platform can markedly reduce the manual work needed to expand the exercise.
How Forvis Mazars & Watershed Can Help
Forvis Mazars and Watershed can help organizations develop a practical, phased approach to Scope 3 reporting that supports compliance readiness, stakeholder transparency, assurance ready data, and long-term sustainability strategy. Because Scope 3 is often the most significant and complex part of a carbon footprint, companies need an approach that is manageable now and scalable over time.
If you have any questions or need assistance, connect with a professional today.