Growth remains a priority for many credit unions. But in an environment marked by higher funding costs, competitive deposit markets, and evolving member expectations, growth alone may not tell the full story. For credit union leaders, a meaningful question may be: Are we creating the right kind of growth?
Answering that question requires looking beyond headline numbers to understand what those numbers represent. From managing the balance sheet and attracting deposits to measuring member engagement and evaluating products, a greater focus on long-term value can help credit unions make more informed strategic decisions.
A Holistic Approach to Interest Rate Risk
Managing interest rate risk can be particularly challenging for institutions carrying longer-duration, fixed-rate assets. Borrowings may help offset balance sheet sensitivity, while interest rate swaps can provide another option for aligning funding with longer-duration assets. For example, pairing shorter-term Federal Home Loan Bank advances with swaps can synthetically create fixed-rate funding for periods where liability sensitivity is greatest. Longer-term swaps also may help manage exposure associated with longer-duration mortgage portfolios.
However, economics are only part of the equation. Using derivatives may require significant upfront work involving policies, counterparties, legal agreements, hedge accounting, and board education. Even when third-party providers assist with accounting and effectiveness testing, management still needs to understand the underlying assumptions and be prepared to explain the strategy. The broader consideration is whether a risk management strategy supports the overall balance sheet rather than simply responding to near-term rate movements.
Beyond the Advertised Deposit Rate
Deposit gathering presents a similar balancing act. When competitors offer attractive certificate specials, matching those rates can seem like a straightforward way to attract or retain funds. But the advertised rate does not necessarily represent the institution’s true funding cost.
Cannibalization can significantly change the economics. When existing members move lower-cost deposits into a promotional certificate, a 4.20% stated rate, for example, could result in an effective cost considerably higher than 4.20%. Requiring “new money” can help mitigate cannibalization, but it may create friction for existing members who do not understand why their long-standing deposits do not qualify for a promotional rate. Some may simply move their funds elsewhere, turning an attempt to lower funding costs into a retention challenge.
The goal should not necessarily be to offer the highest rate. Instead, credit unions can evaluate deposit strategies based on the complete economics, liquidity needs, competitive environment, and member experience.
Member Value, Not Just Member Count
Total membership is another metric that deserves closer examination. Not every member relationship contributes the same value. An indirect borrower who maintains only a nominal savings balance after paying off an auto loan represents a fundamentally different relationship from a highly engaged member with multiple deposit and lending products. Yet both count equally toward total membership.
Credit unions can build a more meaningful picture by supplementing membership totals with measures such as direct versus indirect membership, share of wallet, products per household, and member engagement. One approach is to develop an engagement score based on multiple data points representing how members use the credit union. Tracking engaged-member growth alongside total membership can provide management and the board with greater insight into the depth and quality of member relationships.
The strategic objective then shifts from simply adding members to building relationships that benefit both the member and the credit union.
Product Economics
The same principle applies to product strategy. Credit cards provide a useful example. Competing with large issuers on rewards may seem necessary to earn top-of-wallet status, but increasingly generous rewards do not automatically translate into higher balances or greater interest income. A 2% cash-back program, for example, can increase rewards expense without generating enough incremental balances or interest income to offset the added cost. A tiered rewards structure may offer another approach by aligning higher rewards with transactions that generate greater interchange income.
Credit unions also should consider where they have a meaningful competitive advantage. Matching the richest rewards offered by large national issuers may not be realistic or necessary. A simpler product that provides clear value and fits members’ needs may ultimately prove more sustainable.
A Clearer View of Performance
No single financial metric tells the complete story of a credit union’s performance. Return on assets, efficiency ratio, net worth, liquidity, member growth, loan growth, deposit growth, and member feedback can all provide meaningful information. A balanced scorecard can help bring these measures together, but simply reporting more metrics is not necessarily the answer. Boards also need to understand the trade-offs among them.
Improving one measure may create pressure elsewhere. Pursuing deposit growth can increase funding costs. Accelerating membership growth can add less-engaged relationships. Richer credit card rewards can increase expenses without generating sufficient revenue. Strategic reporting, therefore, should help connect individual metrics with the credit union’s broader objectives.
From Volume to Value
For credit unions, better strategic decisions may begin with asking better questions. Instead of simply asking, Are deposits growing? consider At what true cost? Instead of Are we adding members? ask Are those members engaged? And instead of Can we offer this product or strategy? consider Does it create sustainable value for our members and the credit union?
Growth still matters. But understanding the quality, cost, and sustainability of that growth can provide a more useful foundation for navigating changing conditions and pursuing long-term performance.
How Forvis Mazars Can Help
You do not have to work through these questions in isolation. At Forvis Mazars, experienced professionals work alongside credit union finance teams to provide insight around hedging considerations, deposit pricing analysis, membership analytics, and board-level reporting. Whether your institution is exploring interest rate swaps or reconsidering how it measures member engagement, our team can help support your efforts with practical insight informed by experience serving the credit union sector.
Connect with a credit union advisor at Forvis Mazars to discuss your institution’s priorities and help prepare for what comes next.